Place it right after the confusing line, before the reaction shot, then follow it with Awkward Moment to extend the reaction or Eh Eh Ehhhh to double down on the questioning, keeping this clip as the first beat in the sequence.
Über diesen Sound
This is a very short huh sound effect, lasting under a second, built around a single questioning vocal sound with no words around it. It lands as a quick burst of confusion, surprise and disbelief, the kind of noise you make when something does not add up. Simple, direct and instantly recognisable, it works as a reaction to a strange claim, a bad explanation or an unexpected twist.