Place it at the reveal in an edit, after Sudden Suspense has set up the moment and before the reaction lands. Follow it with Oh My God Wow to let the other person answer the confession, and keep it as the turning point rather than the opening.
Über diesen Sound
This is a very short reaction clip named for Celso Filho and the word Guardei, lasting just over one second. It arrives as a single quick burst that is easy to recognise and reuse in a reply. The feeling is playful and knowing, like a small aside shared between friends when something has been kept back for the right moment.