Place this clip right at the reveal point in your edit, after a sudden suspense beat builds the moment and before you cut to the wider group reaction. Follow it with an oh my god wow from a second person to extend the payoff without repeating the same voice.
Über diesen Sound
A very short voice clip, under a second long, with a person simply saying 'oh wow' as a plain reaction. It gives off clear surprise mixed with disbelief, the small stunned response you make when something unexpected happens right in front of you and a longer reply would take too long.