Put it near the end of a setup about Eli and Nilah, after the evidence has built up, then follow it with the shocked meme sound for the reaction and the illuminati confirmed sound to frame the reveal as a solved mystery.
Über diesen Sound
A short spoken line lasting just under two seconds, it plainly states that Eli likes Nilah in a single quick delivery. The joke lands because the name pairing is so specific, making it feel playful and a little awkward, like calling out a friend's crush in front of everyone. It works best as a light tease rather than a serious statement.