Place it immediately after the confusing statement in your edit, then follow it with Ceeday Huh for a second questioning beat, and close with Oh My God Wow when the reaction needs to escalate. Keep it as the first reaction in the sequence so the later sounds build on it rather than repeat it.
Über diesen Sound
This is a short, roughly three-second reaction clip built around a single incredulous 'what', delivered as if the speaker has just heard something impossible to follow. It feels confused, blunt and funny, the kind of flat disbelief that lands harder than a long explanation. It works best as a quick interruption, cutting in exactly when a conversation stops making sense.