Put it at the turn from setup to discovery, after Sudden Suspense and just before the reveal lands. Follow it with Ceeday Huh for a follow-up reaction, then cut straight to the payoff so the question and the answer stay close together.
Über diesen Sound
A short voice clip, just over a second long, of a guard asking 'What's that?' in a wary, questioning tone. The delivery is blunt and suspicious, like someone has spotted movement in the dark and wants an answer now. It lands as funny and tense at once, perfect for that split second when something unexpected appears and everyone is waiting to see what happens next.