Place it immediately after the unbelievable line, before any explanation, then follow it with Ceeday Huh for a second reaction and finish with Oh My God Wow when the reveal lands.
Über diesen Sound
This clip is a brief 2.2-second vocal reaction built around a single Japanese 'e' sound, delivered as one short utterance. It gives a listener a plain sense of surprise and confusion, the kind that follows a claim that does not add up, without any extra explanation. It works as a quick, deadpan answer when words would only overstate the moment.