Place it right after the unbelievable claim in your edit, then follow it with Oh My God Wow to keep the reaction going before a punchline. For a slower build, start with No No Wait Wait and let this clip close the reaction instead of opening it.
Über diesen Sound
This is a short spoken reaction clip, just under four seconds long, built around the Italian phrase 'Ma come?' followed by a long, stretched 'Nooo'. The voice sounds caught between confusion and disbelief, as if the news in front of it simply cannot be right. It lands as funny and exasperated, the kind of denial that turns a surprising claim into a joke without needing any extra explanation.