Place it right after the reveal in a reaction edit, letting a beat of Sudden Suspense build first so it lands at the peak. Follow it with No No Wait Wait when the story keeps getting worse, or cut to Nelson's Ha-Ha! once everyone realises the claim was a joke.
Über diesen Sound
This 1.7-second clip is a puppet-style voice blurting out the Portuguese 'O quê?', meaning 'What?', in a single burst of pure disbelief. It lands as funny and bewildered, the sound of someone hearing something so absurd they need it repeated. João Seabra performed the voice, using a puppet to imitate a character.