Place it right after the mistake in a clip, with Sudden Suspense just before it and Oh My God Wow following as the next reaction, then finish with Nelson's Ha-Ha to close the clip after the embarrassment.
Über diesen Sound
This is a short spoken exclamation, just under three seconds long, with a single voice blurting out the two-word reaction in a startled, emphatic rush. It feels funny and awkward at once, the kind of instant admission that a situation has just gone wrong. The sudden delivery makes the panic feel immediate, so the listener gets the embarrassment and the surprise in one quick burst.