Place it right after the reveal in your edit, then follow it with Oh My God Wow for a second reaction, or open with Sudden Suspense and let this clip answer the build-up. Knuckles Oh No works as a follow-up when the surprise turns into trouble.
Über diesen Sound
This is a short cartoon clip, just under three seconds long, in which a shark character blurts out a loud, startled OMG in a high, expressive voice. It feels sudden, silly and over the top, like a cartoon double-take that turns a small surprise into a full-blown reaction. It works best as a quick burst of disbelief, delivered with comic timing and no build-up.