Place this clip immediately after the contradictory line in your edit, then follow it with the huh reaction for the confused beat before closing on a wrong answer gameshow sting to underline that the statement cannot stand as said.
Über diesen Sound
This is a 34-second reaction clip centred on a contradiction, the kind of moment where a claim is made and then immediately undercut. It lands as awkward and dryly funny rather than angry, because the backtrack does the work and leaves the listener waiting for an explanation that never quite fixes the first statement.