Place this clip just before the reveal in your edit, after building tension and before the payoff lands. Open with sudden suspense to set up the moment, then let this clip carry the reaction, and follow it with oh my god wow for the second response.
Über diesen Sound
This is an eight-second surprised reaction clip built around a rising, startled vocal sound that stretches the shock out instead of letting it pass in an instant. It feels sudden, wide-eyed and a little awkward, like catching something unexpected mid-sentence and not quite knowing what to say next. The held reaction makes the surprise land harder than a quick gasp would.