Put this clip right after the confusing statement in your edit, then follow it with a bruh soundboard button for a second reaction beat. For a bigger pile-on, layer an oh my god meme sound button after that to close the sequence.
Über diesen Sound
A tiny 0.6-second voice clip says 'This doesn't make any sense' in a processed, voice-changer style. It lands as pure baffled confusion, funny because the delivery is so blunt and immediate. It captures that split second when logic disappears and all you can do is call it out.