Place this clip as the immediate reply shot after the confusing line, then follow it with a bruh for the letdown or an oh my god meme button when the confusion escalates into full disbelief from the whole group.
Über diesen Sound
This is a one-second voice clip of someone asking 'What do you mean Eli' in a flat, puzzled tone. The line lands as pure confusion and mild disbelief, the kind of reaction you give when an explanation makes things less clear instead of clearer, and you need a second to catch up.