Place it immediately after the insult line in your edit, as the direct reply. Lead in with the Law and Order Dun Dun for the accusation, follow with this clip as the defence, then close the sequence without adding another reaction.
Über diesen Sound
This is a nearly nine-second spoken clip of a character angrily defending his goat after an insult, delivered as an exaggerated, possessive outburst. It feels indignant, protective and absurdly funny, turning a minor slight into a full confrontation. It comes from the Helluva Boss short Mission: Chupacabras.