Place this clip right after the confusing statement in your edit, before any commentary from you. Follow it with a huh reaction for a second beat, or precede it with a damn reaction when the reveal needs building up first.
Über diesen Sound
A 20-second voice reaction clip built around the shorthand question 'Y r u h', delivered as a drawn-out, confused response. It gives listeners that stuck, disbelieving feeling when an explanation still makes no sense and you need a second to process what was just said.