Place it at the end of a confusion beat, after Sudden Suspense sets up the moment and before Oh My God Wow reacts to the reveal. That order lets the identity line answer the setup, then hands the moment to a bigger reaction instead of leaving it hanging.
Über diesen Sound
This is a short spoken line, just over a second long, in which a single voice delivers the words 'You should know me' in a direct, knowing tone. It feels confident and a little confrontational, like a quick call-out to someone pretending not to recognise you, and its brevity makes the line land as a sharp, self-assured reaction rather than a longer speech.