Place it right after the reveal in an edit, then follow it with Anime Wow for a second wave of surprise before a Vine Boom closes the moment. That order builds the reaction in stages instead of spending every effect at once, and it keeps the focus on the person reacting.
このサウンドについて
A single human voice holds one long, sliding shout for about four and a half seconds, blending a high 'eeeeh' with a deep, drawn-out 'oooooooh'. It feels exaggerated and gleefully over the top, like a reaction that has gone far past a normal gasp and turned into pure theatre, silly and impossible to ignore.