Place this clip directly after the dubious claim in your edit, then cut straight to the speaker's reaction shot. Follow it with the Dun Dun Dun sound when the doubt needs a dramatic payoff, or precede it with a Vine Boom for an especially unbelievable reveal.
このサウンドについて
This is a 5.6-second vocal clip built around a drawn-out uh-huh, delivered like a flat, unconvinced reply in conversation. It lands as dry and skeptical rather than excited, giving listeners that familiar feeling of being politely doubted, teased, or half-listened to while someone waits for a better explanation to follow.