Put it right after the unbelievable claim in your edit, then follow it with Oh My God Wow for a bigger response, and keep No No Wait Wait for the moment someone tries to walk the claim back.
Over dit geluid
A short 3.5-second reaction clip built around a single shouted Portuguese phrase, 'Aaahhhh meu ovo,' delivered in a stretched, exasperated cry. It lands as comic disbelief, the kind of groan you let out when a claim is too ridiculous to answer calmly, and it works because the frustration sounds immediate and unfiltered.