Put it right after the confusing statement in your timeline, before any explanation spoils the reaction. Follow it with a huh reaction to extend the confusion, then cut to a wrong answer buzzer if the moment turns into a failed guess in your edit sequence.
Over dit geluid
This is a very short spoken clip, under one second long, with a voice asking 'Bebesse foi?' in Portuguese. The delivery lands as a confused, slightly incredulous question rather than a statement. It gives listeners a quick feeling of bewilderment and amusement, like a reaction to something that makes no sense and needs an instant, funny response from the group.