Place it right after the unbelievable line in a short edit, then follow it with Oh My God Wow for a second reaction, or put Sudden Suspense just before it to set up the moment before the reaction hits.
Over dit geluid
This is a short, roughly one-and-a-half-second voice clip of someone blurting out 'eyo WTF' in a sharp, incredulous tone, with the first word stretched out before the blunt second part lands. It feels instantly confused and caught off guard, like a reaction to something completely unexpected, and its blunt, deadpan delivery makes the disbelief land as a quick, funny jolt.