Put it directly after the confusing statement in your edit, before your own response begins. Follow it with the Bruh Soundboard Button for a flatter second punchline, or use the Emotional Damage Sound Button afterwards when the same reveal needs a bigger dramatic fallout.
O tym dźwięku
This clip is a single stretched-out vocal 'eeeehh?' lasting just under two seconds, spoken like a baffled question by one voice. It gives listeners a clear sense of confusion and disbelief, the feeling of hearing something so odd or wrong that you need a moment to process it before you can even form a reply.