Place this clip right after the questionable line in your edit, then follow it with a huh sound button for a second confused beat before closing on a damn meme sound button to sell the disbelief.
O tym dźwięku
This is a short three-second voice clip of a speaker stretching out a hesitant 'uhmmmm' before emphatically saying the name Poseidon. The delivery is drawn out and deadpan rather than shouted. It gives a feeling of playful disbelief and mock confusion, like pausing to question something strange before finally naming it out loud for everyone else.