Place it right after the reveal in a reaction edit, as the beat that answers the claim before the cutaway. Open with Sudden Suspense to build the setup, then follow this clip with Oh My God Wow as the next beat in the sequence.
About this sound
This clip is a single spoken reaction, a voice asking 'You kidding me?' in a flat, incredulous tone, with no music or background effect behind it. It lands as instant disbelief, the kind of stunned, slightly amused reaction you give when a claim sounds too absurd to take seriously, and it works because the delivery stays deadpan rather than shouting.