Place this clip after the failed line in your edit, let the reaction sit as the closing beat, then pair it with an awkward moment sound first in a follow-up cut, or lead into an eh eh ehhhh sound for a second baffled response from another character.
Über diesen Sound
This is a 32-second clip built around a drawn-out, confused huh reaction, stretching a single baffled response far longer than a normal reply. It gives a listener that stuck, disbelieving feeling when a roast or comment makes no sense at all, turning simple confusion into an exaggerated, funny pause that keeps building.