The phrase with a pencil circulates online as a standalone meme fragment, shared on soundboards as a short reaction clip detached from any longer scene. Its popularity comes from how little context it needs: the words alone imply a ridiculous or improbable action was done using the most ordinary object possible. Creators reuse it in edits, streams and short form videos as shorthand for improbable skill, and its very short length makes it easy to loop, layer over other footage or drop into a timed comedic beat.