I Can't Believe It's Not Butter! is a real margarine brand launched in the United States in 1979, and its name doubled as the punchline of its television advertising. The ads, including a long-running 1990s campaign fronted by Fabio Lanzoni, hammered the slogan until it became a pop-culture catchphrase for mock astonishment. Online, the line escaped its commercial roots and now joins the ranks of classic reaction clips such as oh my god, wow, deployed whenever something turns out surprisingly better, or stranger, than expected.