Place this clip at the moment of first sighting, before any reaction lands, then follow it with the Scream Meme Sound Button for the panic and the Bruh Soundboard Button for the deadpan reply from everyone else in the scene.
About this sound
This is a 5.4-second voice clip of someone hesitantly asking 'erm guys is this freddy frazbear' in a flat, unsure delivery. The line lands as awkward and nervously funny, because the speaker sounds like they already know the answer but need someone else to confirm the creepy sight in front of them.