Place this clip right as multiple hands enter the frame for the same object, then follow a successful grab with clapping or a dropped catch with the fail sound to close the gag cleanly for viewers.
About this sound
A split-second chorus of male baseball players all yelling over each other to claim a catch, shouting "I got it," "It's mine" and "Let me have it" in under half a second. It feels frantic, greedy and funny, like a scramble where nobody backs down. The clip comes from the 1942 Goofy cartoon How to Play Baseball.