Place it right after the confusing reveal, then follow with the Bruh Sound Effect for a second beat, or the Oh My God Bro Hell Nah as the next reaction before the cut.
About this sound
This is a roughly 7.7-second spoken reaction in which a single voice drags out the words 'what the hell' with a strained, distorted edge. It feels bewildered and irritated at once, like catching something so wrong that a normal reply will not cover it. The stretched delivery makes the disbelief land harder than a quick exclamation would.